Key takeaways
  • Judge.me holds a 5.0-star rating across 42,604 Shopify reviews; REVIEWS.io holds 4.7 stars across 691.
  • Both apps list a free plan on their Shopify listing.
  • Judge.me's cheapest paid tier is $15/month; REVIEWS.io's is $19/month, with a $45/month tier above that.
  • Both apps also list a $48.47/month price point on their Shopify listings.

01 Quick Verdict

Judge.me and REVIEWS.io are close but not identical: Judge.me carries a 5.0-star rating across 42,604 Shopify reviews, REVIEWS.io a 4.7-star rating across 691. Both list a free plan on their Shopify listing pages, and Judge.me's cheapest paid tier ($15/month) undercuts REVIEWS.io's ($19/month). Both apps also show a $48.47/month price point on their listings.

i
Who this is for: Shopify merchants comparing Judge.me and REVIEWS.io on pricing and star ratings.

Both apps are Shopify review-collection tools for gathering and displaying customer reviews.

02 Pricing Compared

Here's how pricing compares between the two apps, based on their Shopify listings.

Judge.meREVIEWS.io
Rating / reviews5.0 stars / 42,604 reviews4.7 stars / 691 reviews
Listed pricingFree plan available; $15/month; $48.47/monthFree plan available; $19/month; $45/month; $48.47/month

Both apps also list a $48.47/month price point on their Shopify listings.

03 Feature Comparison

Judge.me and REVIEWS.io both offer tiered plans on Shopify, but plan-by-plan feature details — integrations, invite caps, Klaviyo support, Google Seller Ratings — aren't compared here.

04 Ratings and Review Volume

Judge.me holds a 5.0-star rating across 42,604 Shopify reviews. REVIEWS.io holds a 4.7-star rating across 691 reviews. That's a substantial gap in review volume, which likely reflects a larger install base for Judge.me.

05 Who This Is For

The clearest differentiators here are cost and track record rather than features.

  • Consider Judge.me if — a lower entry price matters: its $15/month paid tier is cheaper than REVIEWS.io's $19/month starting paid tier, and it has the larger review count at a 5.0 rating.
  • Consider REVIEWS.io if — its feature set on the Shopify listing fits your needs.

06 Final Verdict

Judge.me has the edge on the numbers: a 5.0-star rating across 42,604 reviews and a cheaper entry-paid tier at $15/month versus REVIEWS.io's $19/month. Both list a free plan and a $48.47/month price point.

07 Frequently asked questions

Which is cheaper, Judge.me or REVIEWS.io?
Judge.me's cheapest paid tier is $15/month versus REVIEWS.io's $19/month. Both also list a $48.47/month price point on their Shopify listings.
Do Judge.me and REVIEWS.io both have free plans?
Yes — both list 'Free plan available' on their Shopify listing pages.
How do Judge.me and REVIEWS.io compare on ratings?
Judge.me has a 5.0-star rating across 42,604 Shopify reviews. REVIEWS.io has a 4.7-star rating across 691 reviews.
What features do Judge.me and REVIEWS.io each offer?
Plan-by-plan feature details for Judge.me and REVIEWS.io aren't covered in this comparison, which focuses on pricing and ratings.
Which one should I choose?
Judge.me has the higher rating, larger review count, and lower entry price.
i
Sources & verification. Ratings, review counts, and pricing verified 2026-07-30 against: Judge.me — Shopify App Store listing · REVIEWS.io — Shopify App Store listing
AM
Alex Mashkovtsev
Founder · Eng Lead at INSO

Alex leads engineering at INSO, an AI-native product & commerce studio. He's shipped custom Shopify apps, checkout redesigns, and theme architecture for brands across the US and EU.