- Printful wins the comparison: the higher Shopify App Store rating (4.8★, 3,627 reviews) and the cheaper paid plan ($24.99/month vs Printify Premium at $39/month).
- Both apps are free to install; paid tiers unlock catalog discounts and additional features beyond the free plans.
- Printify has the larger total review count (4,208 at 4.7★) — a signal of its wider install base — and suits merchants who prefer researching individual print providers themselves.
- Neither app publishes a flat per-item markup — actual product cost depends on the specific item and fulfilling provider or facility.
- Catalog size, shipping speed, and print-quality specifics vary by product and by which provider or facility fulfills each order.
01 Printify vs Printful: the short answer
Printful wins this comparison: it holds the higher Shopify App Store rating — 4.8 stars across 3,627 reviews — and its paid plan costs less at $24.99/month against Printify Premium at $39/month. Both apps are free to install. Printify's strongest counter is its larger review base — 4,208 reviews at 4.7 stars — and it remains the better fit if you specifically want to research and choose among individual print providers yourself.
Beyond ratings and base pricing, sellers typically weigh catalog size, print quality consistency, and shipping speed — factors that vary by product and by which provider or facility fulfills each order.
| At a glance | Printify | Printful |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 4.7★ | 4.8★ |
| Reviews | 4,208 | 3,627 |
| Pricing | Free to install; Premium $39/month | Free to install; paid plan $24.99/month |
02 Pricing compared
Both apps are free to install. On paid tiers, Printify Premium is $39/month and Printful's paid plan is $24.99/month. Both paid tiers unlock catalog discounts and additional features beyond the free plans; the exact perks differ between the two apps.
| Plan | Printify | Printful |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free to install | Free to install |
| Paid plan | $39/month | $24.99/month |
Neither app publishes a flat per-item markup that can be compared cleanly — actual product cost depends on which specific item and which provider or facility fulfills the order.
03 Print quality and fulfillment consistency
Printful holds the higher Shopify App Store rating — 4.8 stars versus Printify's 4.7 stars — a broad signal of overall seller satisfaction, including quality and fulfillment experience. Print outcomes with either app also depend on the specific product and the facility or provider that fulfills each order, so results can vary from item to item; ordering samples before launching is the most reliable way to judge quality for your own products.
04 Which one fits you
- Pick Printful — the default choice: the higher Shopify App Store rating (4.8★) and the lower paid-plan price ($24.99/month vs Printify's $39/month) give it the edge for most stores.
- Pick Printify — if you'd rather research individual print providers, catalog options, and shipping timelines yourself before committing to Premium at $39/month.
Neither app is a fit for merchants whose core need is managing large volumes of design or export files across multiple print-on-demand accounts — that's a file-management problem, not a fulfillment one, and it sits outside what either Printify or Printful (or, for that matter, a tool like Filey) is built to solve for a POD storefront.
05 Printify vs Printful: final verdict
Printful is the winner. It leads on the two clearest verified differentiators: the higher Shopify App Store rating (4.8★, 3,627 reviews) and the cheaper paid plan ($24.99/month against Printify Premium at $39/month). Printify's larger review count (4,208 at 4.7★) signals a wide install base, but it doesn't offset a lower rating and a higher paid-plan price. Both apps are free to install.
Catalog breadth, provider network, shipping speed, and packaging options still vary with the specific products you sell — check them against your own lineup — but on the numbers this comparison can verify, Printful is the pick.
07 Frequently asked questions
- Is Printify or Printful cheaper for Shopify sellers?
- Both apps are free to install. On paid plans, Printful is cheaper at $24.99/month versus Printify Premium at $39/month.
- Which app has better print quality, Printify or Printful?
- Printful holds the higher Shopify App Store rating at 4.8 stars (3,627 reviews) versus Printify's 4.7 stars (4,208 reviews). Print outcomes with either app also vary by product and by which facility or provider fulfills the order, so ordering samples is the most reliable way to judge quality for your own store.
- Are Printify and Printful free to use on Shopify?
- Yes — both apps are free to install on Shopify. Printify's Premium plan costs $39/month and Printful's paid plan costs $24.99/month for additional features and discounts.
- Should a new Shopify store choose Printify or Printful?
- Both are viable starting points since both are free to install. Printful offers a higher App Store rating (4.8★) and a cheaper paid plan ($24.99/month); Printify has a larger review count (4,208) but a pricier paid plan ($39/month). Catalog breadth and shipping speed vary by the products you sell, so weigh those against your planned lineup.